Should I paint cedar shake and vinyl siding the same color?

No, it's best not to paint cedar shake and vinyl siding the same color. Instead, use the vinyl’s warm cream or beige as a base and select a contrasting, saturated color for cedar shake, such as deep teal or vine green. This approach highlights the natural texture of cedar and adds dimension to the exterior while maintaining harmony. Adding cream trim ties the two materials together without making the design look flat or budget-driven.